Predicting the Equity Premium: The Advantages of Combination Forecasts
نویسندگان
چکیده
While a host of economic variables have been identified in the literature with the apparent in-sample ability to predict the equity premium, Goyal and Welch (2007) find that these variables fail to deliver consistent out-of-sample forecast gains relative to the historical average. In this paper, we demonstrate that despite the failure of individual predictive regression model forecasts to outperform the historical average, combinations of individual model forecasts deliver statistically and economically significant out-of-sample gains relative to the historical average on a consistent basis over time. Why do combination forecasts deliver consistent out-of-sample gains? We argue that the data-generating process for the equity premium is highly complex and subject to substantial structural instability, and Hendry and Clements (2004) show that combining forecasts across individual models can lead to improved forecast accuracy in such an environment. To provide further insight into the relevance of this, we test for potentially multiple structural breaks in individual predictive regression models of the equity premium. We find extensive evidence of breaks, suggesting that the usefulness of combination forecasts stems in large part from their ability to improve equity premium forecasts in the presence of widespread structural instabilities. In addition, we find evidence of structural breaks in predictive regression models that use the same set of economic variables to predict real output or corporate profit growth, and there are a number of cases where the breaks in predictive regression models of real output or corporate profit growth occur relatively near the breaks in predictive regression models of the equity premium. Structural breaks in the dynamic behavior of the real economy thus help to provide an economic explanation for the structural instabilities in the dynamic behavior of the equity premium. Overall, our results indicate that the underlying processes driving the equity premium cannot be adequately captured by a single, relatively parsimonious predictive regression model. JEL classifications: C22, C53, G11, G12
منابع مشابه
Out-of-Sample Equity Premium Prediction: Consistently Beating the Historical Average
While a host of economic variables have been identified in the literature with the apparent in-sample ability to predict the equity premium, Goyal and Welch (2007) find that these variables fail to deliver consistent out-of-sample forecast gains relative to the historical average. Imposing theoretically motivated restrictions on individual predictive regression models, Campbell and Thompson (20...
متن کاملA Quantile Regression Approach to Equity Premium Prediction
We propose a quantile regression approach to equity premium forecasting. Robust point forecasts are generated from a set of quantile forecasts, using both xed and time-varying weighting schemes, thus exploiting the entire distributional information associated with each predictor. Further gains are achieved by incorporating the forecast combination methodology in our quantile regression setting...
متن کاملForecasting Equity Premium: Global Historical Average versus Local Historical Average and Constraints∗
The equity premium, return on equity minus return on risk-free asset, is expected to be positive. We consider imposing such positivity constraint in local historical average (LHA) in nonparametric kernel regression framework. It is also extended to the semiparametric single index model when multiple predictors are used. We construct the constrained LHA estimator via an indicator function which ...
متن کاملLet’s Do It Again: Bagging Equity Premium Predictors
The literature on excess return prediction has considered a wide array of estimation schemes, among them unrestricted and restricted regression coefficients. We propose bootstrap aggregation (bagging) as a means of imposing parameter restrictions. In this context, bagging results in a soft threshold as opposed to the hard threshold that is implied by a simple restricted estimation. We show anal...
متن کاملEquity Premium and Dividend Yield regressions: A lot of noise, little information, confusing results1
Suppose that the equity premium is forecasted by dividend yields. Even if such a relationship does exist, there is so much noise in the equity premium that estimation, inference and forecasting cannot be carried out using the faint signal coming from the dividend yields. For analyzing equity/dividend data, it is useful to quantify the signal in a given sample. We de ne an index of signal streng...
متن کامل